What Details Do Teachers Expect From Student Proofs? A Study of Proof Checking in Geometry
Search for other papers by Justin K. Dimmel in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Search for other papers by Patricio G. Herbst in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
We investigated how secondary mathematics teachers check student geometry proofs. From video records of geometry teachers checking proofs, we conjectured that teachers have different expectations for details that follow from written statements than for details that are conveyed by diagrams. To test our conjectures, we randomly assigned 44 secondary mathematics teachers to 1 of 3 experiment groups (n & 13, n & 15, n & 16) in which they viewed and rated representations of instructional practice. Participants in each group viewed treatment or control versions of instructional scenarios and rated the appropriateness of the teachers' work in different segments of each scenario. We compared participants' ratings across and within experiment groups. We found that participants rated lower instruction that deviated from what we hypothesized to be their expectations, confirming our hypotheses.
Contributor Notes
Justin K. Dimmel, College of Education and Human Development, University of Maine, 330 Shibles Hall, Orono, ME 04469; justin.dimmel@maine.edu
